Police Culture and Transformational Leadership: Outlining the Contours of a Troubled Relationship

Abstract

For a number of years there has been a sustained acknowledgement of the worth of ‘transformational’
leadership as a catalyst for change within police organizations. Academics, policy makers, and senior officers alike
have pronounced the benefits to be enjoyed from the implementation of such leadership models, not least in respect of
promoting cultural change. However, this article will present a counter argument to suggest that the application
of transformational leadership models to policing contexts is worthy of more robust critique which, to date, it has
been subjected to. In doing so, this article explores the concept of ‘transformational’ leadership and its relevance
to policing contexts. Additionally, the article will suggest that claims of success in effecting cultural change within
police organizations are likely to rest on simplistic conceptions of police culture and its relationship to police
behaviour